For most people, mechanical watches come nowhere near to being better than quartz. This is because electric watches are considered better than mechanical watches. However, is that personal opinion or are there specific qualities that quartz watches have that triumph the features of mechanical watches?

Quartz is a good option if you desire high accuracy, don’t hate depending on batteries, and don’t care about exclusivity. Quartz is also renowned for its affordable pricing. But on the other end, if you prefer complex and artistic machinery and independence from batteries, choose mechanical watches.

It seems there is always a debate about whether or not one kind of watch is better than another. Most people try out different kinds of watches throughout their lives and amass quite a collection. However, does there tend to be a preference for quartz watches over mechanical watches? Here is why most people think quartz watches are better than mechanical watches.

Which Is Better Between A Quartz And A Mechanical Watch?

Quartz timepieces are clearly superior at first glance. However, when thinking about which is better between the two watches, that generally need to be in some context. What you like genuinely is entirely up to you. It all depends on what you look for in a watch. Is it the brand value or the aesthetics? Precision and dependability? Durability?

Quartz is battery-powered, whereas mechanical watches tend to be manually or automatically wound. This is where most of the significant distinction is there. However, there are other factors to consider when deciding which is better. The major distinction between quartz and mechanical watches typically boils down to accuracy, durability, and cost.

Furthermore, it is irrelevant what sort of watch you choose over the other when accuracy and durability have no bearing on your decision. However, you must comprehend why quartz precisely triumphs if both of the qualities mentioned above are of the utmost importance.

The Accuracy And Durability Of Quarts And Mechanic Watches

A sequence of gears that work together to provide the motor in a mechanical watch is inherently subject to wear and tear friction and other possible problems as you use the watch. As time passes, this unquestionably leads to some accuracy problems and the watch’s lifespan along with it.

Simply put, mechanical watches, particularly elaborate ones with features like a perpetual calendar, a moon phase indicator, etc., are better works of art than quartz watches, which are more accurate. Quartz watches, in contrast, perform the identical transference without utilizing even one moving component.

The quartz crystal is used as a medium for oscillating electric charges. This enables an exactness that mechanical watches cannot match. The absence of any mechanical failure possibility suggests great durability.

Additionally, contemporary mechanical timepieces go beyond the fundamental chronometric functions. Chronometers and calendars are included in the list of other pointlessly complicated feature sets that most of these timepieces have.

Each of these details adds a new degree of complexity and increases the possibility that mechanical problems could arise somewhere within the ever-expanding network of gears. The more accurate, functional, and affordable technology is quartz.

Mechanical watches are more comparable to early gear and spring tech. And because people tend to collect older items, mechanical is more in demand as a collectible. Mechanical obviously isn’t as shock-proof as quartz because it uses gears and other things to operate. A slight fall could alter the time. The quartz ranges’ robust, shock-proof, and dependable qualities have been praised.

Cost And Maintenance Of Quartz Vs. Mechanical Watches

Around 5-7 years, mechanical watches require maintenance. The cost of upkeep for most mechanical counterparts is high. There is no doubt that quartz is nice because they are completely accurate. However, batteries will be needed. Although they have a rather lengthy lifespan, it can be inconvenient when they do run out.

Some pay $15, while others spend up to $40 just to get a new battery. This may not seem like much, but you can start to question whether it is really worth it. Quartz vibration is used for a quartz watch’s seconds, minutes, and hourly hands to function.

Since battery power is required for this operation, the quartz watch will stop functioning when the battery is depleted, and the lifespan of an average battery is reduced. In comparison to mechanical timepieces, the battery needs replacing after a typical lifespan of roughly two years.

There are two types of mechanical watches, namely manual and automatic. The mainspring of a manual mechanical watch is wound more tightly, which pushes gears that move the seconds and minutes hands. Swinging is how a mechanical, completely automated watch keeps running. Mechanical watches are more expensive to maintain and, in some ways, more prone to breakage.

This means that you won’t have to worry about having a battery problem. However, does that pro beat the quartz pros? Also, let’s face it, mechanical timepieces outperform their quartz rivals in aesthetic appeal. The massive system of gears spinning away with the ticking of each passing moment is utterly mesmerizing. Mechanical watches also have investment and collector value, which is a bonus.

It is clear that they each have their good points. You must pick what characteristics of the watches are significant to you before answering the question. If accuracy is crucial, quartz is probably better. If craftsmanship is significant, mechanical begins to overtake it.

Other factors that choose mechanical over quartz are longevity and environmental friendliness. Cost and the capacity to withstand short-term misuse favor quartz greatly. Once you’ve established what matters, choosing tends to come naturally.


Quartz watches have continuously excelled and survived their mechanical relatives. While less captivating, a quartz watch is much more effective at what it is meant to do: accurately track the passage of time.

But at the other end, mechanical timepieces are subject to a wide range of mechanical problems and degrade over time. This is particularly relevant in light of the needless intricacy many mechanical models choose to incorporate only for aesthetic reasons.


Similar Posts